I reserve my opinion columns for really obvious stuff. That’s for a number of reasons, but mainly because I don’t want to wade into highly controversial topics if I’m going to need to report on them objectively and with fairness.
Reporters traditionally have had to be really careful about this stuff, but as I’m also editor and publisher of this news outlet and I have 20 years of experience watching and reporting on the local scene and seeing how things work, I’m invoking some executive privilege here and there and commenting on topics I feel are important to the communities I cover.
Even with straight reporting, I’ve become more and more convinced that reporters should just call things as they are, rather than platforming absurdity.
I recently did it on the benefits of stop signs, and I’m going to do it here on a topic that shouldn’t be controversial: If big-box stores aren’t appropriate for large commercial zones with wide-open spaces, what should go there?
I’m speaking, of course, about Costco coming to Rhode Island. First we had the ridiculous narratives that it wasn’t actually going to happen just because they hadn’t submitted a plan yet (they still haven’t, as of Nov. 5. I checked). Now we have people from Smithfield organizing opposition and believing they will be able to block the project based on, you won’t believe it … traffic counts. Just because defeating big business on this premise has never happened before, they say, doesn’t mean it can’t happen.
Listen, NIMBY-ism (not in my backyard-ism) is a real and sometimes beneficial thing. Some people mock it, I get it. People want to keep looking at the woods behind their home. NIMBY-ism is going to keep happening as long as we have projects going into residential areas. Some projects are just really bad or not right for an area, and they should be rejected. Others deserve public comment about detrimental effects because they need to be made better.
But if we can’t agree that a new big-box store that will bring great shopping options, lots of tax money, and many jobs (some paying quite well) to a large vacant lot in a high-traffic commercial corridor with no houses around (area of Routes 7 and 116), we don’t deserve any nice things.
The public meetings when Costco does submit its application will likely be very long, because one person after another will get up and tell everyone how this store is going to create more traffic problems for the area. Newsflash: That won’t be enough to deny the project. I would say that your best bet is to stake out a spot and wait for an endangered dragonfly or two, but the former Smithfield Peat site was cleared and used for commercial purposes for decades.
At first I was shocked at the opposition. I get that some store owners don’t like it because they think it will take some business away from them, but when Walmart was open on Diamond Hill Road in Woonsocket, it drove thousands of extra customers to the area. Those people stop at local restaurants, convenience stores, and other types of businesses. When Walmart left for neighboring North Smithfield, traffic cratered. Guess who suffered? Small businesses, taxpayers, the city as a whole.
There’s a balance, for sure. Big-box stores can and do hurt others and put them out of business, but that will never be looked at by any judge as a valid reason to reject a project.
I suppose I shouldn’t shut the door completely on opponents’ chances of success in this quixotic fight. Who knows, maybe if you’re loud enough, Costco will decide that the good people of Woonsocket deserve a new store on the re-emerging Diamond Hill Road.
By Ethan Shorey, The Local Insider





