SCITUATE – If town voters’ recent choices are any indication, they want more transparency in their local government.
For the second straight election, Republican Theresa ‘Terry’ Yeaw finished as the top vote-earner, but she was unendorsed by her local party and remains very much an outsider due to her frequent calls for greater transparency, advocacy for a home rule charter and other actions.
Adding credence to the idea that voters might want a new dynamic, they placed independent Richard Finnegan a close second, a mere 59 votes beneath Yeaw on the list of seven winners, at 2,463 votes to Yeaw’s 2,522 votes.
Endorsed Republican Jason Parmelee, who has frequently remained silent with his colleagues when Yeaw has made a motion for discussion on a topic and not had it seconded by anyone to even open up the floor, came in last place and off the council. Councilors Timothy McCormick and Gary Grande did not seek re-election, but five other Republicans rounded out the top seven this month.
Now there’s a movement afoot through an active petition, joined by the town’s Democrats, to get Yeaw elected president of the council, a role often a given when someone wins the most votes in a local race in Rhode Island. Yeaw herself is also lobbying for residents to support the petition before the new council is sworn in and new leadership is chosen in January.
Current Council President Charles Collins Jr. finished in seventh and in the final spot to win a council seat, coming within 17 votes of missing out on a seat. Collins finished in third place two years ago, when overall votes were much higher and President Trump won by a wide margin in town.
Advocates say Yeaw can be the bridge between parties in the town.
Names of petitioners will be verified for residency before being presented to the new council, according to the petition.
“That is no small accomplishment. It represents the confidence, trust, and support of the residents who took the time to cast their ballots,” said Yeaw in a post-election message. “When voters repeatedly show that level of confidence in an elected official, it deserves to be recognized when leadership positions are decided.”
She said she is a veteran councilwoman who brings experience, knowledge, and a genuine commitment to the people of Scituate.
“I have demonstrated a willingness to ask difficult questions, seek answers, stand up for transparency, and hold town government accountable,” she said. “Leadership isn’t simply about holding a title or presiding over meetings. It’s about having the courage to address difficult issues, listening to residents, making informed decisions, and putting the interests of the community ahead of personal interests. Scituate needs a Town Council president who leads with honesty and integrity, values open government, and understands that the council is accountable to the people it represents.”
She said she has demonstrated those qualities through her years of service.
“While the selection of council president is ultimately the responsibility of the Town Council, the voices of the voters should carry considerable weight. Being the highest vote-getter in two consecutive elections sends a strong message about whom residents trust to represent them,” she said.
“This is not about political favors or personal alliances. It is about recognizing experience, respecting the voters’ choices, and selecting leadership that reflects the values our community deserves.”
She is encouraging everyone who supports her to sign the petition and join her at the January meeting.
Scituate is perhaps Rhode Island’s most conservative town. Voters here gave John Loughlin his widest margin of support in any community, at 62.08 percent to 37.68 percent for Sabina Matos, and also made the town one of few communities to support independent Ken Block, giving him 43.01 percent of the vote to 36.62 percent for Democrat Helena Foulkes and 19.17 percent for Aaron Guckian. The town resoundingly rejected all but one of the state’s spending questions on the ballot, but approved the green economy jobs question, 52.67 percent to 47.33 percent.
Yeaw and Finnegan were among those active at the polls during early voting, collecting signatures for a home rule charter in Scituate.

Scituate will be 300 years old in five years, and the town’s lack of a home rule charter governing its operations has been a point of controversy for a long time. Advocates such as Yeaw and Finnegan have persistently pushed for this layer of accountability, even as they’ve also criticized other councilors on a host of topics, including handling of the senior tax freeze.
Scituate is run by its council and municipal department heads and does not have a top executive.
Shaina Smith, chairperson of the Scituate Democratic Town Committee, shared her reasons for advocating for Yeaw as council president.
“When Terry reached out to me for technical assistance to get this online petition off the ground, I did not hesitate to step in and help collect signatures alongside her,” she said. “That decision had nothing to do with party labels and everything to do with what this effort represents: women’s rights, fairness, equality, and true democratic accountability. In an at-large Town Council election, earning the highest number of votes is the clearest signal voters have to express confidence in a candidate’s leadership. In a town without a Home Rule Charter to establish formal rules for selecting leadership, allowing the Council to choose its own President only works when the board demonstrates objectivity and fairness.”
Added Smith, “Over the past two years, the current Town Council body has shown an inability to set aside internal politics and personal agendas. After bypassing Yeaw in 2024 for president, despite her finishing first at the polls, her colleagues repeatedly refused to show the mutual respect required for open, collaborative governance, leaving her motions unseconded and blocking public discussion on critical town matters, including the senior tax freeze controversy. When a governing board shuts down debate rather than answering to residents, we the people have every right to get involved; in this particular instance, we’re insisting that the electorate’s top choice be given the gavel.”
She continued, “But let me be clear: this is not simply about a number on a ballot; it’s about demonstrated integrity. While Democrats and Republicans certainly differ on policy issues, Yeaw has consistently proven that she puts Scituate residents ahead of party loyalty. She ran unendorsed by her own party at her request while still earning the top spot on the ballot in back-to-back elections. While some may disagree, I feel this demonstrates voters across party lines trust her judgment.”
Said Smith, “Outside of putting aside political ideologies for local decision-making, Yeaw has repeatedly pressed for public answers and accountability regarding the administration of the senior tax freeze ordinance, even when standing alone on the Town Council. As a veteran councilwoman and active supporter of local initiatives such as the Scituate Sustainability Committee and Home Rule Charter reform, she engages with residents openly rather than limiting public input. She also attends more local events than any other Town Council member; I’ve often found myself bumping into her at weekend or weekday programs held throughout Scituate.”
She said, “Finally, my decision to encourage our committee’s involvement to support Yeaw’s campaign for Town Council president is deeply rooted in fairness, respect, and supporting women in public leadership. Watching the only woman serving on the outgoing Town Council have her motions left without a second by an all-male majority sends a troubling message about whose voices are valued in town government. Unfortunately, that lack of respect extends beyond the Council table.”
Said Smith, “I have experienced firsthand how dismissive members can be toward women participating in local government, including during public comment and at the annual Financial Town Meeting, where council members were visibly and/or audibly disrespectful, either whispering among themselves while a woman was speaking at the microphone or abruptly interrupting the person’s comments. Supporting equal respect, open debate, and women stepping into leadership roles are core principles I refuse to compromise on, regardless of party label.”
She stated, “With several incumbents returning to local office due to uncontested races, this petition is how Scituate voters can put the Town Council on notice. It’s a collective message confirming that good governance requires objectivity, equity, and accountability.”




